Swish Appeal: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: MLB Trade Deadline: Who is available around MLB?

Marie Hardin, an associate professor of journalism and associate director of the Center for Sports Journalism at Penn State University, wrote the following today about why "we're generally not willing to support women in team sports":

"Team sports are usually contact sports, and that's the bigger issue, I think. Women in sports that involve varying degrees of contact -- from the individual sports of boxing and wrestling, to team sports such as basketball -- challenge traditional ideas about femininity. And that's why they don't get the media attention or public attention they might otherwise deserve."

It's an interesting contrast to the attention given to physical play in women's basketball and the suggestion that increased physicality could in fact increase interest in the game.

Which brings us back to the question: is increasingly physical play good for women's basketball, especially if that poses a direct challenge to "traditional ideas about femininity?

Update from Helen at the Women's Hoops Blog: "physical contact might lead to physical intimacy."

5 months ago Natehead_tiny Q McCall 5 comments 0 recs  | 

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Pin-up vs. Warrior

Well, that is quite a notion, and could explain the dismissive attitude some males (and females) assume toward women in team sports. As a middle-aged straight woman with a college-aged daughter, I find the sight of Talia Caldwell leaping for a rebound inspiring rather than threatening. Clearly it’s disturbing to others, and rather than just saying, “Gosh, that disturbs me,” they retreat to their inner 14-year-olds and mumble, “Chicks are no good at team sports.” Yeah, right: Girls are yucky, girls have cooties.

Anyway, of course “increasingly physical play” is good for the game; apart from the excitement of physical play, it’s also inevitable, it’s change and growth and all that. Good grief, there was a time when women played half court and were restricted by actual rules about their moves. (Diana Taurasi would have been considered a freak, instead of an unusually strong and smart athlete.) “Traditional” femininity has become a construct used by advertisers; the real thing is more complex and more interesting.

(My big brother in Seattle loves basketball, and follows the Storm. For his 70th birthday, I sent a mock congratulatory e-mail from Lauren Jackson, and included the following link: http://olympicgirls.net/girls/basketball-girls/ The idea of game face coexisting with traditional feminine/sexy drag might bother some—it certainly bothered my sister-in-law!—but I wish more men and women could be this, , , perhaps “fluid” is the word.)

by BearBint on Feb 18, 2010 11:39 AM EST reply actions  

""Traditional" femininity has become a construct used by advertisers; the real thing is more complex and more interesting."

This is true…but it’s also reinforced in daily interactions by men and women alike… marketing and social norms are sort of mutually reinforcing in that regard, no?

Calming the inner 14-year-old is no small task though: as evidenced by the Olympic luge, putting boys and girls on equal fitting, even by accident is troubling for some people…

SwishAppeal.com, women's basketball...covered SBN-style... twitter: @qmccall3

by Q McCall on Feb 18, 2010 11:58 AM EST up reply actions  

Even the luge didn’t put them on equal footing. The men took off from the women’s start, but the women got moved down too.

CGB: Wasting Your Potential, Your Time, & Your Life Since 2006.

by BearStage on Feb 20, 2010 3:15 PM EST up reply actions  

“physical contact might lead to physical intimacy.”

hahaha what??

CGB: Wasting Your Potential, Your Time, & Your Life Since 2006.

by BearStage on Feb 20, 2010 3:14 PM EST reply actions  

Homophobia and women's sports...

An interesting extension of Hardin’s argument…but what do you think?

If femininity = heterosexuality in the minds of the inner-14-year-old, then physical contact could be a problem for some…

I just don’t see that as the primary factor, to be honest…

SwishAppeal.com, women's basketball...covered SBN-style... twitter: @qmccall3

by Q McCall on Feb 20, 2010 3:36 PM EST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Dedicated fans honoring the beauty and skill of basketball.
Start posting on Swish Appeal »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

SBNation.com Recent Stories

 LeBron James, Dwyane Wade and Chris Bosh of the Miami Heat speak after being introduced to fans during a welcome party at American Airlines Arena on July 9 2010 in Miami Florida.  (Photo by Doug Benc/Getty Images)

How Good Will LeBron James And The Miami Heat Be In 2011? Hint: Very Good

Lorenzen Wright 
(Getty Images) +6 updates

Lorenzen Wright's Body Found In Memphis, Police Conduct Homicide Investigation

Chris Paul LeBron James

'The Miami Model': Why Greed Is Good, And The NBA's Superteam Era Will Be Great

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

Natehead_small Q McCall

Seth_avatar_bw_small Seth Pollack

Editors

Background2_small Queenie

Reffeet_small freelantz

Authors

Lacy_small petrel

Maya_small Scotter

Cass_and_trevor_small iamtrevorpaxton

Dsc_0250_2_small LJRotter

Womens_hoops_card-p137020233376503137tdn0_210_small Dishin

Sam_small_small Sam James